Before the Pumpkin
The pumpkin on the porch last night was the easy version. Before it, in Ireland and Scotland, the lantern was a turnip: small, hard, pale, and reluctant. You did not carve a turnip because it wanted carving. You carved it because metal lanterns were dear, the night was Samhain, and a face with a coal inside it, set by a door or a window, might persuade wandering spirits — and one particular wanderer — to keep walking.
The wanderer's name was Jack. In the Irish tale — first in print in the 19th century, though the carving is older than the story told to explain it — Stingy Jack tricked the Devil twice: once into a coin kept beside a silver cross, once up a tree with a cross carved in its bark. So when Jack died, heaven would not take him, and the Devil, bound by his bargain, would not either. He was sent into the dark with a single burning coal, which he carried in a hollowed turnip. The lights seen over bogs at night were said to be his lantern, still moving.
The pumpkin inherited the face.
The turnip kept the wandering.